Welcome Back, Donald

Have you heard the story of Donald Herbert, the New York firefighter who very suddenly — after almost ten years without speaking — sat up and said, “I want to talk to my wife”?

Donald had been very seriously injured in December, 1995, when the roof of a burning building collapsed and pinned him underneath. Experts estimated he was without oxygen for six minutes. Over the past ten years, Donald has been almost completely blind and struggling with rehabilitation. His memory was nearly completely gone; he was unable to recognize family and friends, and he had very little ability to communicate. In fact, simple monosyllable responses were all he could muster, and those were exceedingly infrequent. Until Saturday.

On Saturday, Donald suddenly came to life. He sat up and told a member of the nursing staff that he wanted to talk to his wife. When they called his house for him, his 13-year-old son answered the phone. “Impossible,” thought Donald, “he’s not old enough to talk.” Donald spent the next 14 hours talking almost incessantly and was up most of the night visiting with his family and friends with whom he had been suddenly reacquainted. Some of them he recognized by their voices, even though he hadn’t remembered hearing them for a decade.

Doctors are a little baffled. Though these cases are extremely rare, they do happen, often without any known impetus. People do sometimes emerge from the most remarkable situations and, in some cases like Donald, show little signs that anything was ever wrong.

Welcome back, Donald. I’m thrilled for you and your family. May God continue to bless and keep you.


  1. A positive story out of my hometown, for once 🙂

  2. The Light Fantastic May 5, 2005 at 4:39 am

    Wow! That’s an amazing story.

  3. What a wonderful story…. To have missed so much in his life must be soo traumatising, but its heartening to hear of his recovery and i wish him all the best for what will probably be another tough time for him during his recovery.

  4. God is above all. He may not keep u happy and healthy all the time… but someday, sometime, He will surely reach out 2 u

  5. What an amazing story!!

  6. Iam happy for him.

  7. wow, and no one has compared his case to the Schivo [sp?] case…I guess that would be uncomfortable.

  8. David BC Tan May 6, 2005 at 6:51 am

    inspiring story – yes, i did mention Schiavo in my post about Herbert and wondered the same thing…

  9. this is what its all about, now if only this would happen to everybody else we’d alot more wonderful outcomes.

  10. It’s not comparable to the Schiavo case…this gentleman wasn’t kept alive by tubes and wasn’t in a persistent vegitative state.I THOUGHT I saw the other day that he had slipped back down again. I hope now maybe I misread what I saw.

  11. I thought he slipped back under again after that amazing streak of talking.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *